30 Years for a Rape He Never Committed
Cornelius Dupree Jr. celebrates his victory and freedom.
Rape, genuine rape, in which the right perpetrator has been charged, tried and convicted, belongs at the top of society’s most heinous crimes. It’s hardly an accident that judges and juries have a tendency to rush to judgment once they are convinced that the correct person is on trial.
The problems arise when the evidence is faulty, the investigation sloppy and the prosecution more concerned with victory than justice.
In recently published reports, from the Associated Press and other new outlets, the saga of Cornelius Dupree Jr., unfolded. He spent 30 years wrongfully imprisoned in connection with a rape and robbery case in Texas, where an amazing number of rape convictions have been overturned because of prosecutorial mistakes, mis-informed witnesses or newly acquired DNA evidence.
A week ago, Mr. Dupree told reporters that “it is a joy to be free again” after being officially exonerated in a Dallas courtroom.
Dallas County Courthouse
The focus for much of this delayed justice, finally realized has to again be on Barry Scheck and his staff at the Innocence Project, the organization behind many of these exonerations, including Dupree’s, according to the published sources.
As the AP accounts explained it, Scheck said that, “It’s a great tribute to Cornelius and his spirit that he was able to fight this long and this hard to win his freedom,” said Scheck, who sat next to Dupree in the car as they drove away.
Dallas has so many exonerations not because it was more egregiously unjust than other counties in Texas, but because unlike other jurisdictions, Dallas County kept the DNA evidence refrigerated and stored for decades. That’s what saved these men. What convicted them was erroneous eyewitness testimony.
Of the 21 men exonerated in Dallas, 20 were convicted on the strength of the victims’ identification. That, in turn, has pointed the finger at the police and prosecutors who are now themselves accused of pushing rape victims to make cases. Scheck says that’s what happened in Dupree’s case, too.
“The kinds of eyewitness procedures that were used in his case were ridiculous,” Scheck said. “And they are the reason that he was wrongfully convicted.”
Another one of the reasons these exonerations are happening in Dallas is because it elected Craig Watkins, Texas’ first black district attorney. Before becoming DA, Watkins was a defense attorney who says he saw firsthand how the county sometimes railroaded poor black men.
Watkins’ willingness to work with the Innocence Project has not made him popular with many of his colleagues and some lawmakers in Austin.
“It’s been proven that the system needs to be fixed, and we know actually where we can fix it,” Watkins said. “How about those people who are in positions of power and influence getting on board?”
Dupree wasn’t let out of prison because he was innocent; he was finally paroled in July after serving 30 years. He says he’s not angry, but does harbor some resentment.
“I do have some ill feelings, you know, in terms of how the system went. I had to take so long to finally bring this to light,” Dupree said. “It was so many losses; that’s what hurts me the most.”
Dupree says he just wants to live quietly now and try to enjoy his life.
For a similar local story, follow this link to philly.com to learn about Larry Peterson who was found innocent of rape in New Jersey.
Leave a Response